The Labor Government’s fanfare budget policy “Future Made in Australia” is going to hit the headlines again this week as it finally finds its way to the agenda.

Titles like this seek to inspire our sense of patriotism, and to see the Government as on the side of making Australia a self-sufficient place, where home grown manufacturing businesses can thrive.

But as with most political headlines they can be, well, misleading to say the least. The better test of any policy or initiative is to look at the outcomes.

While I don’t claim to be able to see into the future as to how this policy will deliver, I do know that past performance can be a strong indicator of future success.

Two years ago, Labor announced the National Reconstruction Fund (NRF) with the stated aims to, “… provide finance in the form of debt, equity and guarantees for projects in the priority areas of the Australian economy”.

This gave birth to the Industry Growth Program (IGP) designed to “Support innovative small to medium enterprises (SMEs) and startups to commercialise their ideas and grow their businesses”.

Grand words, but what are the outcomes two years into this project?

Industry representatives have told me that the requirements built into the NRF regarding the shares of equity within those businesses make it almost impossible for any small business to be able to secure funding, indeed, the only businesses big enough to qualify for the fund would not need the funds in the first place.

To their knowledge, no money has gone out to small business from the NRF.

Similarly, those working with small businesses say that while the IGP have been inundated with applications, not a single dollar had gone out to small businesses in the two years since it was established until, hey presto: an announcement on Monday, just ahead of the parliamentary sitting week.

When most of us think about manufacturing, we imagine cavernous warehouses involving heavy industry, but manufacturing is not a particular “sector”, it is in fact a capability.

My own electorate of Fowler is replete with manufacturers. More than 600 of them manufacture products from food and building materials, to medical supplies and for the recycling industry; employing 40 per cent of workers.

Australia has over 47,000 small businesses, and only a handful of large businesses; what we are missing is medium sized businesses. For smaller manufacturing companies to grow and develop into globally competitive markets, they need investment. They need government to remove obstacles.

Shocked by the reports that I was hearing that NRF funding had failed to reach any small manufacturing businesses, I decided to use my question to the Prime Minister on May 28 to ask whether this was true: “How much of the $15 billion announced in 2022 has been allocated to support small and medium sized manufacturing companies in Western Sydney?”

The Prime Minister, not surprisingly, did not answer my question.

Despite the efforts of the Leader of Opposition Business and The Speaker, Mr Albanese could not address the question, but spoke about road building in Fowler. The reader may draw their own conclusion as to why he chose not to answer my question and the fact that announcement of funding followed.

The Prime Minister did end by proclaiming the benefits of the NRF making decisions “at arm’s length” from government.

Again, I was contacted by a small manufacturing company who applied for funding but was refused by the NRF.

His experience was that the makeup of the investment team of the NRF, though well intentioned, did not possess the breadth of industrial domain understanding. Nobody on the team has any food manufacturing background, for example, yet this is a key sector of manufacturing in Fowler and many other electorates.

Worryingly, it is possible that the NRF is being used to establish and support bureaucracies which may have the best intentions but will have failed in their task if funding is not sent promptly on to small businesses.

While I welcome funding for 80,000 fee-free TAFE courses, I am concerned this has been funded by the NRF. Feeding the bureaucracies that administer funding will not, by itself, encourage manufacturing.

In principle I share the aspiration of a future made in Australia, but I want more than statements of intent; I want delivery, and I want to make sure that it is set up in a way that is not only fair to all who might seek investment, but also able to assess applications from as wide a field of manufacturing as possible. They need to do it quickly. Australians are fed up with punchy slogans with no beneficial outcomes.

Dai Le is the independent federal MP for Fowler.

(This appeared in Daily Telegraph, Sydney)